As for criticizing you personally, if you don't like it, then don't ask for it.
That was your reply to my quite fitting constructive criticism. And this has been your typical modus operandi each time you've graced this board with your visits, throughout the years: Show some laughable (or cryable), ridiculous garb... er... stuff; and then defend it, and argue, and defend it some more... Now the wiki ship descriptions are "boring", according to your high-most standards for excellence, so you're going to unfold your amazing artistic skills and improve upon the guidelines...Ares wrote:WHO'S NEXT? WHO'S NEXT? Who else wants to question my reading and cannon-ness abilities?
No offense of course
This does nothing for vegastrike, and it does nothing for your skills (except maybe it gives you writing and arguing practice).
And it's true that nobody is paying anyone a salary; this IS an open source endeavor. But Open Source doesn't imply that it's a free-for-all, or that this art vetting forum is a public garbage dump. The expectations ought to be lower than in a commercial enterprise, but not by much: Modelers are not easy to come by, but some put in some real effort and real work, and make things that at least try to fit the guidelines. In other words, you DO face some competition, here; but it doesn't seem to me you're even aware of the fact.
But to get back to topic...
Simple constructive criticism: Remove those ridiculous "wings", remove that ridiculous tube of a body, then start again, and do something half decent. And put some frigging details. And try to make things make at least a bit of sense, even if "it's just a game". Cut down on the attitude and defensiveness. Learn Blender, if at all possible within your busy scheule. And try to look at your own work with a critical eye before you post it, if you don't want others to tell you the things you don't want to hear. Finally, I would advice you take upon a small fighter. Carriers and large ships are work for the pros, and what you've shown here has never been as good as to even be considered beginners' level. Start small, do something constructive with constructive criticisms, instead of arguing, and finish something, for a change; --textures and everything.